Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Work Hours
Monday to Friday: 7AM - 7PM
Weekend: 10AM - 5PM
For U.S.-based Amazon sellers and eCommerce brands, choosing between Fulfilled by Amazon (FBA) and Fulfilled by Merchant (FBM) can feel like a make-or-break decision.
While FBA offers Prime eligibility, convenience, and automated logistics, its rising fees and rigid systems can shrink margins—especially for sellers dealing with heavy, customized, or low-volume products.
By contrast, FBM—where sellers manage their own storage, packing, and shipping—offers flexibility and cost control that FBA simply can’t match. Here’s how to decide when FBM is the smarter, more profitable choice in 2025.
💰 The Core Advantages of FBM
FBM gives sellers full control over fulfillment. The three biggest benefits are:
- Cost Control – Avoid FBA’s growing storage, picking, and packing fees.
- Inventory Autonomy – Manage your own stock levels, storage locations, and fulfillment methods.
- Brand Customization – Personalize packaging, delivery experience, and post-sale interactions.
For niche brands or regional sellers, these advantages often outweigh FBA’s convenience—especially when paired with a strategic logistics setup.
1️⃣ Selling Heavy or Oversized Products
Why FBA Fees Crush Profit Margins
Amazon’s FBA fees are heavily weight-based. For large items like furniture, gym equipment, or appliances, those costs can eat your profits fast.
A 150-pound treadmill, for example, might face $100+ in FBA fees on a $500 sale—leaving little room for profit.
How FBM Solves It
FBM sellers can:
- Negotiate carrier rates (FedEx, UPS, or regional couriers).
- Use local 3PLs to reduce shipping distances and warehouse costs.
- Avoid long-term storage surcharges for slow-moving stock.
🪑 Case Study: A U.S. furniture brand switched to FBM for its oversized sofas. By using a Texas-based 3PL, fulfillment costs dropped 40%, and profit margins increased from 15% to 25%.
2️⃣ Selling Custom or Handmade Products
Why FBA Falls Short
FBA’s standardized processes don’t accommodate personalized, made-to-order, or fragile items—like engraved jewelry, custom apparel, or artisanal goods.
These products require special packaging, inspection, or final assembly, which FBA simply doesn’t support.
FBM’s Edge for Custom Orders
FBM gives sellers freedom to:
- Include personal notes, gift boxes, or brand inserts.
- Inspect items before shipping to ensure quality.
- Offer expedited or local delivery for time-sensitive orders.
💍 Example: A jewelry brand uses FBM to add handwritten thank-you cards and branded packaging for engraved rings, leading to higher reviews and repeat purchases.
3️⃣ Managing Low-Volume or Seasonal Products
The FBA Risk
Amazon’s monthly storage fees—and especially Q4 peak rates—can devastate margins for slow-moving SKUs.
For example, a $200 specialty part selling only 5 units per month might still rack up $30 in storage fees, cutting profits by 15%.
The FBM Advantage
FBM uses a pay-as-you-ship model: you only incur costs when products sell.
This makes FBM ideal for:
- Niche products
- Seasonal items
- High-ticket goods with irregular demand
📦 Pro Tip: Use FBM for SKUs selling fewer than 10 units/month, and track performance through tools like InventoryLab or SoStocked to avoid overstocking.
4️⃣ Leveraging Regional Fulfillment Efficiency
Why FBA Can Be Costly in Remote Areas
FBA’s centralized warehouses often increase delivery times and shipping costs to states like Alaska, Hawaii, or Puerto Rico.
How FBM Wins Regionally
Sellers operating in regional markets can use local couriers or 3PL partners to ship faster and cheaper.
🏄♂️ Example: A Hawaii-based surfboard seller switched to FBM and used regional couriers for 2-day delivery—cutting logistics costs by 30% and improving customer satisfaction.
🧭 Bonus Tip:
FBM allows you to fulfill across multiple channels (e.g., Amazon + Shopify + Etsy) using one centralized inventory system—something FBA doesn’t allow.
5️⃣ Maintaining Full Inventory Control
The FBA Limitation
FBA restricts warehouse space and imposes inventory limits—especially during Q4 or Prime events. You might find yourself unable to send enough stock when demand spikes.
FBM’s Advantage
FBM gives sellers full flexibility to:
- Adjust inventory levels instantly.
- Test new products without minimums.
- Use eco-friendly packaging aligned with brand values.
📈 Data Insight: Sellers using FBM report 20% higher inventory turnover thanks to faster restocking and better forecasting.
⚖️ FBM vs. FBA: Which Is Right for You?
| Factor | FBA | FBM |
|---|---|---|
| Product Type | Lightweight, high-turnover | Heavy, custom, or niche |
| Sales Volume | High (50+ units/month) | Low (5–10 units/month) |
| Geographic Reach | Nationwide (Prime eligible) | Regional or flexible |
| Control Level | Limited | Full control |
| Storage & Fees | Fixed + seasonal surcharges | Pay-as-you-go |
🧩 Decision Rule:
If your products fit 2 or more FBM scenarios (e.g., heavy + low volume), FBM is likely the more profitable model.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions About FBM
Q1: Does FBM affect my Buy Box eligibility?
Not necessarily. FBM sellers can win the Buy Box by maintaining competitive prices, fast shipping, and strong seller ratings.
Q2: How do I manage returns with FBM?
You’ll handle returns yourself, but you can use Amazon’s Return Processing Portal for automation. Set clear return policies (e.g., 30-day returns) to maintain customer trust.
Q3: Can I switch between FBA and FBM for the same SKU?
Yes. You can use Amazon’s Inventory Placement Service to split stock or list the same product under both fulfillment options.
🧠 Final Thoughts: When FBM Is the Smarter Play
FBM isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution—but for U.S. sellers handling heavy, customized, or slow-moving items, it offers superior control, flexibility, and profit potential.
By aligning your fulfillment strategy with product type, sales velocity, and regional logistics, you can lower costs, improve margins, and scale more sustainably on Amazon.
Next Steps:
- Audit SKU-level profitability.
- Test FBM for slow movers or oversized products.
- Partner with regional logistics providers to optimize fulfillment.
📦 Smart fulfillment = Sustainable growth.